Are you intelligent, open minded and able to recognize candor when you see it. Or are you blinded by ideology?
The test involves FIRST reading the New York Times description of George W. Bush's final press conference.
Now compare it to the Wall Street Journal version which I have included below. Both are about the same length, fairly short.
By JOHN D. MCKINNON, WASHINGTON
-- President George W. Bush called a surprise farewell news conference
Monday to give an accounting of his time in office, making new
concessions to his critics while offering sometimes-emotional defenses
of his handling of Iraq, Hurricane Katrina and the war against
terrorism.
During Monday's 47-minute morning news conference, Mr. Bush recalled the urgency that he and his aides felt after the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, as they searched for the proper responses, and hinted that his critics at home were only adding to the problems.
"You remember what it was like right after September the 11th around here?" he asked. "People were saying, 'How come they didn't see it? How come they didn't connect the dots?' Do you remember what the environment was like in Washington? I do. When people were hauled up in front of Congress and members of Congress were asking questions about, 'How come you didn't know this, that or the other?' And then we started putting, you know, policy in place, legal policy in place, to connect the dots. And all of a sudden people were saying, 'How come you're connecting the dots?'"
As a result, he said, "In terms of the decisions that I have made to
protect the homeland, I wouldn't worry about popularity," he said.
"What I would worry about is the Constitution of the United States, and
putting plans in place that makes it easier to find out what the enemy
is thinking, because all these debates will matter not if there is
another attack on the homeland."
He denied that the U.S. has lost moral standing around the world as a result of its response to 9/11, except among "some of the elite." He added that "people still understand America stands for freedom, that America is -- is a country that provides such great hope."
Mr. Bush also defended the administration's response to Hurricane Katrina in 2005. The huge storm unleashed flooding that devastated New Orleans. He said he has "thought long and hard" about the hurricane response, but concluded that he would have hindered rescue efforts if he had personally visited the stricken area sooner -- a sore point for critics.
He added later that the administration's broader response had been misjudged. "You know, people said, 'But the federal response was slow,'" Mr. Bush recalled. "Don't tell me the federal response was slow when there was 30,000 people pulled off roofs right after the storm passed....That's a pretty quick response."
He conceded that other aspects could "have been done better," an
apparent admission that the federal effort to tend to other victims --
such as those in the Superdome -- was inadequate.
In other areas, Mr. Bush was conciliatory to his critics. He termed the Abu Ghraib prison scandal in Iraq "a huge disappointment," while the failure to find weapons of mass destruction in Iraq was "a significant disappointment" given intelligence assessments. He repeated his admission that the "Mission Accomplished" banner on a U.S. aircraft carrier "sent the wrong message."
"I don't know if you want to call those mistakes or not, but they were -- things didn't go according to plan, let's put it that way," he said.
He also acknowledged that the administration made a mistake in 2005 in seeking to overhaul Social Security. He said the White House should have pursued immigration reform instead. His push for Social Security personal accounts fell flat amid bipartisan opposition.
Mr. Bush had warm words for President-elect Barack Obama, calling him "a very smart and engaging person" and wishing him the best as he assumes office Jan. 20.
Offering a personal reflection on the extraordinary -- sometimes
exhausting -- times in which he has led, Mr. Bush spoke of the pressure
that comes with the office, predicting that "there'll be a moment when
the responsibilities of the president land squarely on his [Mr.
Obama's] shoulders....All I know is he's going to feel it. There'll be
a moment when he feels it."
But he held out hope for the Obama administration's prospects, despite the tough economic times and the constant threat of a terrorist attack on U.S. soil. "President-elect Obama will find, you know, as he makes these tough calls and tough decisions, that he'll be supported by a lot of really good people that care -- care about the country as well," Mr. Bush said.
The president said Mr. Obama's election reflects a welcome breakthrough for U.S. race relations. "I consider myself fortunate to have a front-row seat on what is going to be a historic moment for the country" when Mr. Obama is inaugurated, Mr. Bush said. "It's going to be an amazing, amazing moment."
On Thursday night, Mr. Bush plans to deliver a farewell address to Americans. He is expected to look back on his time in the Oval Office and the changes the country has made. In addition, he is expected to offer his assessment of the biggest challengers the nation faces and recommendations on how best to meet them.
As for the political future, he said Republicans can recover from their recent setbacks, as they did after Barry Goldwater's defeat in 1964. But to do so they must become more inclusive.
"We've just got to make sure our message is broad-gauged and compassionate and that we care about people's lives and we've got a plan to help them improve their lives," he said.
As for himself, Mr. Bush suggested he is likely to stay involved in policy matters, including a planned book. "I'm a Type A personality," he said. "I just can't envision myself, you know, the big straw hat and Hawaiian shirt sitting on some beach."
Recent Comments